yarn along: finally off the needles!

IMG_1219

One of these days I am actually going to get around to posting this on Wednesday when everybody else does.

I finally finished kitting the striped Classic Raglan for Carter. I used two shades of Lion Bran Fisherman's wool.  The sweater was not supposed to be striped, but I accidentally grabbed the wrong color when I was at Hobby Lobby.  Since the travel time to the store is 2 hours round trip, I decided to go with stripes.  This was my first attempt at stripes an the pattern doen' allow for them so it took a little math to determine how many rows I needed of each and where the decreases would go.  In the end I went with 12 rows of each color (give or take  - allowing for miscounts).  I am very happy with the result.  This time around I made a size 6.  I know it is big for him now, but I am pretty sure he will be getting a few years out of it.  I am a bit concerned about the neck being too small for his head, but trying to wrangle a wiggly two year old into a thick sweater when the heat index is 115 degrees is not an easy task.  He is also really disturbed by the  "bits" hanging down.  I guess I'll have to get on weaving in those ends before I try to yank it over his head. 

I have had Radical Homemakers by Shannon Hayes on my "To Read" list since it came out in 2010.  I am about halfway through and I am still not sure what to think of it.

In many ways I think she is right on in her analysis of  the problems with our current culture and the dangers of relying too heavily on the extractive consumer based economy.  She basically argues that a more sustaining and sustainable culture is one that nourishes and honors family, community, social justice, and ecological sustainability.  According to Hayes, and her subjects, economic wealth is far less important than well-being, which demands that we as individuals and a society do much more than earn and spend x amount of dollars.  I am in love with her vision of society.  It is radical.  It suits my values and my beliefs.  It is a bit on the utopian side, but I like that.  I think it is important to think beyond our current reality and imagine a different kind of world.  And what she is describing is a different kind of world - one that pays homage to the past but has not existed before.

Hayes often looks  to the past for cues about what a better future could and should look like.  However, I think her vision of the past is a bit romanticized (granted I have not finished the book).  Yes, men and women worked together, but it was couched in terms of a deeply patriarchal society.  The vision Hayes promotes is one where mutuality, equality, and parity are more entrenched in married relationships than they were in the past.  This new type of relationship is something worth celebrating, and it is a reality that has come about because of feminism.

And so we get to one of my critiques of the book.  I have deep reservations about whether returning to a family based economy can be a viable feminist project in a world that has not fully embraced feminism and is in many ways still deeply patriarchal. I'm not saying you can;t be a feminist and a homemaker.  Far from it - I think the two must go together.  If you are a regular reader, you know this about me.  So, I'm not trying to be pessimistic.  I just worry about backsliding.  I'm not quite ready to say that feminism has failed to make women's lives better.  It has.  I have an advanced degree in what used to be a male dominated field.  Are there problems? Certainly.  However,  I don't think this means that women will never be able to enjoy their place in the professional world.  I do like that she discusses the productive role of women in the home and takes women's work in the family economy seriously.  I have long believed that one of the major problems with some feminist thought is that it too readily dismisses traditional women's work and skills. I could spill volumes on this topic.  I probably should write more so that my points are more clear.  But I will leave the topic here. 

A second critique of the book is pretty similar to a point Terra made in the comments section of my last post.  I think that many of the participants in Hayes study did not have to start from scratch.  To be fair, this is a central part of her argument - that if we move away from individualistic thinking, are willing to ask for and give help to others in our families and communities we will all be better off.  I wholeheartedly agree.  However, what about hose who do not have and inheritance or nest egg to kick start the process.  What about those who, for whatever reason,  can't rely on family to help?  How do we move towards living a life based on the principles outlined in the book?  I imagine she covers this topic in the pages and chapters I have not finished.  At least I hope she does.  Because despite my criticisms here, I am totally inspired by the families she writes about and the lifestyle she describes.  I am just wondering about the logistics of making it all happen - of starting from scratch. 

So, at the midpoint, I have to say that I am really enjoying the book and I am completely inspired.  I know I have complained here before about the lack of community and networks I have here in Tennessee, but I really do need to start reaching out more and this book is inspiring me to do that.  I need to be more proactive in building a community of people around me.  To do that, I have to get over some of my shyness in meeting new people and set aside a little bit of my pride and ask for a helping hand now and then.

I hope I haven't been too harsh here.  I really an enjoying the book.

2 comments:

  1. Like you, I completely support homemaking from a feminist standpoint - it's been really hurtful to feel like these choices aren't valued from a feminist standpoint. But I'm not going to lie, the choices I've made definitely tie me to the house more than I always want. It's not a problem for me because of who where I live and who I live with - BUT yes, I do see how problems could arise and it goes from choices to coercion to oppression. I am reminded of just how women, even in the so-called modern societies, are still viewed every time I read something controversial written by a woman and then the comments. Frankly, it's terrifying.

    Another thing I guess I find disingenuous is the "opting out" of things like consumerism, healthcare - big corporation things, but then allowing people who probably live the norm give you money and land etc. I don't really think that's opting out, I think there's just an extra step involved in supporting these things. I understand not wanting to personally be involved, but the whole thing seems weird and misleading to me. I know not everyone lives like that, which I guess goes back to the whole "how do you start from scratch" question. I might just have to get this book. I admire a lot of what Hayes stands for - I think the general ideas are fantastic. I'm probably expecting too much!

    Thanks Jaime, for reviewing what you've read. I don't know anyone else whose read it, so I'm glad to have your opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Jaime,

    It sounds like an interesting book. You got me intrigued even though I'm not "a homemaker". Well, I guess Patrick and I work at home so maybe we're both homemakers. :)

    It's a big topic you tackled here and I don't feel qualified to even comment. Patrick and I are very progressive so we don't have traditional roles of who does what. The only exception is bug catching. I made a deal with Patrick a long time ago that he take care of the bugs. :) He's cool that way. Everything else is up for grabs. (We both cook, do dishes, mow grass, run power tools....)

    Anyways, it sounds like an interesting book and I wonder if you've finished by now!

    ReplyDelete